24

2010

-

06

Steel ball grading for cement mills

Author:


After the mill has been in operation for a period of time, balls must be replenished every 7 to 10 days, which can lead to a highly disordered ball-size distribution. The longer the mill operates, the more ball sizes are present, making it increasingly difficult to accurately calculate the ball-size distribution. When a small mill is emptied for maintenance, the ball mix can be carefully calculated and the balls sorted by size before being added, ensuring that the resulting size distribution closely matches the calculated values.

After the mill has been in operation for a period of time, balls must be replenished every 7 to 10 days, which often leads to a highly disordered ball-size distribution. The longer the mill runs, the greater the number of ball sizes present, making it increasingly difficult to calculate the optimal ball gradation. For small mills, when the mill is emptied for cleaning, the desired ball mix can be accurately calculated, the balls can be sorted by size and then added in accordance with these calculations, resulting in a gradation that closely matches the theoretical values. In contrast, for large mills, the sheer volume of grinding media makes size sorting extremely time-consuming, thereby complicating production scheduling. As a result, most operators do not follow this systematic approach; instead, they manually remove worn balls, iron slag, and undersized balls according to their own specifications, then compare the actual replenishment with the standard addition amount. If the replenishment falls short, they typically add the largest-sized balls or, based on experience, supplement with other ball sizes. Consequently, both the ball-size distribution and the average ball diameter are only rough estimates and lack precision.

In-mill measurement status

Specifications: mm Φ100–95, Φ95–85, Φ85–75, Φ75–65

Entrances: 28,362,718

Exports (units): 24,204,025

Average: 262,833.521.5

The calculated theoretical total weight (with Φ100–95 mm balls treated as Φ100 mm balls) is 295.8 kg.

Proportion of various steel balls:
   26 × 4.115
Φ100 = ────── × 100% = 36.2%
      295.8 
   28 × 3.111
Φ90 = ────── × 100% = 29.4%
      295.8 
   33.5 × 2.107
Φ80=──────×100%=23.9%
      295.8 
21.5 × 1.498
Φ70 = ────── × 100% = 10.9%
    295.8

Weights of steel balls at all levels

Specifications (mm): Φ100, Φ90, Φ80, Φ70

Weight (t) 7.96 6.47 5.26 2.40

The weight-average particle diameter can then be calculated as: 89.4 mm.

The calculated average particle diameter is:

26×100+28×90+33.5×80+21.5×70 9305
────────────────── =────≈85.4mm
  26+28+33.5+21.5 109

The calculation results were broadly consistent with the actual situation. At the time, the mill discharge fineness was excessively coarse; upon shutting down the mill for adjustment, calculations indicated that 5 tonnes of Φ100–95 mm balls should be removed and replaced with 1 tonne of Φ90 mm balls and 4 tonnes of Φ80 mm balls, thereby bringing the fineness in line with specifications. Trial runs demonstrated that this approach is relatively accurate and effective for monitoring the internal conditions of the mill and resolving operational issues.