28
2011
-
02
Correct Method for Calculating the Optimal Ball-to-Material Ratio in Ball Mills – China Cement Technology Network
Author:
Steel grinding balls are critical fundamental components of ball mills, with precision industrial steel balls playing a particularly significant role in national economic development. They are widely used in cement plants, power plants, and other industries. High- and low-chromium multi-element alloy steel balls, as well as high- and low-chromium multi-element alloy castings and forgings, also play a vital role in national economic development.
Steel grinding balls are essential basic components of ball mills, with precision industrial steel balls playing a particularly significant role in national economic development. They are widely used in cement plants, power stations, and other industries. High- and low-chromium multi-element alloy steel balls, as well as high- and low-chromium multi-element alloy castings and forgings, also exert a major influence on national economic development. Under certain special operating conditions, steel balls made from specialized materials are often required to meet the functional demands of different environments. In fact, such specialized steel balls have already been extensively applied across various sectors of the national economy, including high-chromium steel balls and forgings, low-chromium steel balls and forgings, chromium-series lining plates, manganese-series lining plates, hammerheads, multi-element alloy steel balls, multi-element alloy lining plates, and a wide range of wear-resistant materials. The widespread adoption and application of these products have not only spurred the development of the ball-mill steel-ball manufacturing industry but have also promoted technological advancement and scientific progress in related industries.
After a period of operation, ball mills require replenishment of grinding media every 7 to 10 days, which can lead to a highly disordered gradation of the steel balls. The longer the mill runs, the greater the number of ball sizes present, making it increasingly difficult to accurately calculate the desired ball-size distribution. For small mills, during shutdowns for emptying and cleaning, the optimal mix can be precisely calculated; the balls are then sorted by size and added in accordance with these calculations, resulting in a gradation that closely matches the theoretical requirements. In contrast, for large mills, the sheer volume of grinding media makes manual sorting both time-consuming and impractical, thereby complicating production scheduling. As a result, most operators do not follow this systematic approach. Instead, they selectively remove worn balls, iron slag, and undersized balls according to their own criteria, then compare the actual addition with the standard recommended charge. Any shortfall is typically made up by adding the largest-sized balls or, based on experience, by blending in other ball sizes. Consequently, the calculated ball-size distribution and average ball diameter are only rough estimates and lack precision.
Global Heavy Industry has applied a simple calculation method in practice, which involves using probabilistic methods and mathematical induction for sampling calculations. This approach offers some reference value and is described as follows: A square frame with 500 mm sides is constructed using No. 8 steel wire; the mill is emptied of its charge, the mill door is opened to enter the mill, and two locations—one at the inlet and one at the outlet of the grinding chamber—are selected. At each location, three radial measurements are taken, as shown in the figure.
Count the number of steel balls of various sizes that have more than half of their diameter exposed within the square grid, record the results, and then organize and analyze the data to obtain a reasonably accurate ball-mill steel-ball gradation. An example of measurement data is shown in Table 1.
|
Specifications mm
|
Φ100 ~ 95
|
Φ95 ~ 85
|
Φ85 ~ 75
|
Φ75 ~ 65
|
|
Entrances (units)
|
28
|
36
|
27
|
18
|
|
Exports (units)
|
24
|
20
|
40
|
25
|
|
Average
|
26
|
28
|
33.5
|
21.5
|
Table 1: Measurement Results Inside the Mill for a Specific Instance
The calculated theoretical total weight (with Φ100–95 mm balls treated as Φ100 mm balls) is 295.8 kg.
Proportion of various steel balls:
The total grinding media charge is 22 t, from which the weights of the steel balls in each size class can be calculated (see Table 2).
|
Specifications (mm)
|
Φ100
|
Φ90
|
Φ80
|
Φ70
|
|
Weight ( t )
|
7.96
|
6.47
|
5.26
|
2.40
|
Table 2: Weights of Steel Balls at Various Grades
The weight-average particle diameter can then be calculated as: 89.4 mm.
The calculated average particle diameter is:
The calculation results were broadly consistent with the actual situation. At the time, the fineness of the product leaving the mill was excessively coarse; during the mill shutdown for adjustment, calculations indicated that 5 tonnes of Φ100–95 mm grinding balls should be removed and replaced with 1 tonne of Φ90 mm balls and 4 tonnes of Φ80 mm balls, thereby bringing the fineness up to specification. Trial tests demonstrated that this approach is relatively accurate and effective for monitoring the internal conditions of the mill and resolving operational issues.